Countries Have No Duty To Admit 13 Children From 3 Marriages In Yemen, Rules Top Human Rights Court
The short version
- The ECHR dismissed the migrant's complaint on Tuesday, holding that Council of Europe states are not required to treat polygamous family arrangements as they would a monogamous…
- The man, 56, has three wives and 13 children from those unions.
- After arriving in the Netherlands in 2018 and receiving asylum, he was allowed to bring one wife and their eight children.
- Dutch authorities refused entry to the five children born of his other two marriages , citing that "polygamy is prohibited in the Netherlands." He lost his challenges in the Dutch…
- He argued the case was not about importing polygamy, because he was not seeking to bring the other two wives, only the remaining children.
The story
A Yemeni asylum seeker living in the Netherlands cannot rely on family reunification rules to bring over children from two additional marriages that Dutch law does not recognize, ruled the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). The ECHR dismissed the migrant's complaint on Tuesday, holding that Council of Europe states are not required to treat polygamous family arrangements as they would a monogamous household.
The man, 56, has three wives and 13 children from those unions. After arriving in the Netherlands in 2018 and receiving asylum, he was allowed to bring one wife and their eight children.
Dutch authorities refused entry to the five children born of his other two marriages, citing that "polygamy is prohibited in the Netherlands."
He lost his challenges in the Dutch courts and then turned to Strasbourg, according to French newspaper Le Figaro. He argued the case was not about importing polygamy, because he was not seeking to bring the other two wives, only the remaining children. The court rejected the argument that the refusal violated his right to respect for family life.
If a European state "establishes an immigration policy that takes family ties into account," it "cannot be obliged to recognize polygamous marriages that conflict with its own legal system," the judges in Strasbourg ruled.
🇩🇪A tale of two Germanys🇩🇪
— Remix News & Views (@RMXnews) April 28, 2026
🔴The first Germany represents illiterate Syrian migrant Ahmad A. and his 2 wives and 6 children. The entire family received free housing and welfare thanks to German taxpayers.
"I would to thank Mommy Merkel very, very, very much," he told Spiegel… pic.twitter.com/dywvPx6m9K
The court also noted that he could have divorced the two other wives, as Dutch authorities had proposed, but declined to do so.
Notably, the second wife is already in the Netherlands with her children after she received asylum in June 2025. However, the fact that she entered the Netherlands did not change the ruling, the ECHR stated.
"The fact that polygamy is prohibited in all member states of the Council of Europe shows that there is a strong European consensus on this issue," the judges noted. Under those circumstances, "Member States have considerable discretion as to whether or not to grant fathers and children born of polygamy the right to family reunification."
🇫🇷🚨In France, an Ivorian polygamist has been sentenced to 30 years in prison for torture, rape, and for imposing a hard-line Islamic regime on his 4 wives and 29 children.
— Remix News & Views (@RMXnews) December 4, 2025
The 45-year-old Ivorian migrant, held in pretrial detention since 2022, was said to have stripped the home… pic.twitter.com/1NVsbWmJcl
The ECHR, based in Strasbourg, oversees compliance with the European Convention on Human Rights by the member states of the Council of Europe.
Related Markets
All MarketsMarket data may be delayed. Not financial advice.
Powered by Gab AI
The Story At A Glance
Reading this article now — analysis appears below
💡 AI analysis provides alternative perspectives on current events
